Wedding Day

Co-Cathedral of St. Robert Bellarmine

Ceremony

American Hotel

Reception

After Party

Our Wedding

It began at Loyola University in Baltimore, Maryland, where a guy from Pittsburgh and a gal from New York crossed paths in a way that felt ordinary at first—but would turn out to be anything but. He met her through a Pathways leadership event hosted by her roommate, and left thinking to himself, 'the blonde one is pretty cute.' On the other hand, she was not so sure about one of her roommate's mentees being her boyfriend. During a walk through Sherwood Gardens, they would share their feelings about one another and C.J. tripped over a tree root, which sent him tumbling to the ground. He quite literally had fallen for Amanda.Over time, Amanda, who once insisted she didn't want to date him slowly fell too—this time without tripping. Through college days, late night studying at the security desk in Flannery hall, and across oceans in long distance talks while abroad, their love grew. Not even a global pandemic could keep them apart! Eleven years passed not in a blur, but in thousands of shared moments that built a love rooted in patience, friendship, and deep understanding.In November 2025, C.J. asked the most important question of all, and Amanda said, "yes!" (not without shedding a few happy tears first). What started with hesitation, playfulness, and a literal fall became a love story filled with loyalty and care for each other. We are so excited to celebrate our journey that brought us here—and dance the night away with you all on March 13, 2027!

Literally Falling in Love!

Our Story

Gallery

Best friends since before high school started. Chrissy and Amanda met at "Girls Just Wanna Have Fun" Night; an accepted students night for those possibly attending Good Counsel Academy. Chrissy's been a constant source of joy, loyalty, and wisdom throughout Amanda's life. They both got engaged last year and went through the wedding planning process together. Amanda couldn't be more grateful for Chrissy to be by her side through this season of life (and for many more to come).

The Future Mrs. Christina Chin Ortiz

Although it didn't begin that way (they formally met in CCD religion class), Katie and Amanda became best friends in high school. They've spent many sleepovers staying up well past midnight, mall trips, and summer beach days talking about their adventures and listening to each other yap. Finally, they both found love and their late night chats became a reality. Katie's been a tried and true friend though life's ups and downs  -  and Amanda couldn't be happier to have her stand by her side on the BIG day.

Katie Scharf

Through good luck, Connor and CJ were enrolled in a pre-fall orientation program at Loyola and quickly became friends. They bonded over a mutual interest in music, sports, and movies, which only allowed their friend group to grow when meeting new people on campus. After their first year on campus, they decided to become roommates and it stayed that way until graduation. CJ knew Connor would be his best man because he met Amanda on day 1, knows CJ better than most people, and cares deeply about the people close to him. 

Connor Giblin

CJ's best friend since childhood. Zach's a major Pittsburgh sports fan and golfer. He's one the best hype men you could ask for! CJ met Zach in first grade, all the way back in Mrs. Bell's class. Zach has always been able to bring the best out of all people, including CJ. When Amanda first visited Pittsburgh, she remarked how Zach and the rest of CJ's friends made her feel welcomed. On their wedding day, the bride and groom know with Zach by his side, they are going to be at their best. 

Zach Tamilia

Wedding Party

We have a room block reserved at The American Hotel for March 12, 2027 through March 14, 2027. If you'd like to book a room, please call the front desk: 732-431-3220 to make a reservation and ask for the Puglise|Atkison Wedding. Please make your reservation by February 6th.

There is an additional room block set up at The Radisson Freehold. If you'd like to book a room, please call the front desk:&nbsp;732-780-3400. to make your reservation. Remember to ask for the Puglise|Atkison Wedding for the discounted rate. You may also copy and paste this special link below into your browser: http://www.choicehotels.com/reservations/groups/WZ14G1 and input the date(s) of your choosing to make reservations. Kindly make your reservation by February 12th.

Radisson Hotel Freehold

Travel

The Bagel Nook in Freehold, NJ, is&nbsp;a popular bagel shop renowned for "overload" bagels, featuring creative combinations like Oreo, Fruity Pebble, and Flamin' Hot Cheeto bagels, along with over 50 unique cream cheese flavors. While you're in Jersey, trust us, get a bagel.

The Bagel Nook

If you know the bride-to-be, she believes donuts can fix just about anything! These cake-style donuts are made hot to order so eat them in store. Enjoy some fried dough in honor of the upcoming marriage :)

Broad Street Dough Co.

A staple in Freehold known for legendary thin-crust pizza and Italian dishes. The Boss, Bruce Springsteen, and Bon Jovi, have been seen frequenting the spot as one of their "favorite" pizzerias in the area.If you've found this page, you know the couple ready to exchange nuptials are big foodies!

Amanda & Craig

Amanda & Craig

Gallery